Flight 93 Update

Mother of Flight 93 hero calls for “a full and transparent review” of the crescent-shaped memorial

Blogburst logo, petition

For two years, Tom Burnett Sr. has been speaking out against the crescent-shaped memorial to Flight 93. This week Beverly Burnett (mother of Flight 93 hero Tom Burnett Jr.) stepped into the public eye to support her husband, and to make her own appeal for a full investigation:

Today, I am adding my voice for a full and transparent review of the National Park Service and Flight 93 design selection process that produced Crescent of Embrace. Does it have Islamic symbols or doesn’t it? Let’s settle this once and for all.

Why do you think Tom Sr. opposed this design? It is pretty simple; Tom Sr. saw the Islamic symbols and knew those symbols did not belong at the crash site of Flight 93.

Tom Burnett Sr. traveled to Pennsylvania last August to attend the Task Force Meeting to voice his opposition to the memorial design. A Family Board member as well as a commissioner accused Tom Sr. being “just like the Islamic terrorists” that killed our son.

Why didn’t someone speak up and defend Tom Sr.’s right to voice his opinion?

Thanks to The Somerset Daily American for publishing Mrs. Burnett’s complete statement, which she also entered into the record of the most recent Memorial Project meeting. Read the whole thing.

Two other mentions of the memorial controversy in the local PA press this week

In a letter to the editor, a local woman echoed Mrs. Burnett’s sentiment in favor of preserving the site as it is, instead of demolishing the highly regarded Temporary Memorial and radically transforming the landscape, as the Memorial Project intends.

At present the Temporary Memorial looks down over the “field of honor.” Because this temporary memorial is located roughly in the center of the planned half-mile wide crescent, it will be eliminated. Visitors who stand at the location of the Temporary Memorial will no longer look out over the original landscape, but will instead see the crash-site framed between the pincer tips of the giant Islamic-shaped crescent.

They call the crescent a broken circle now, but the unbroken part of the circle, what symbolically remains standing in the wake of 9/11 (originally called the Crescent of Embrace) remains completely unchanged.

Nice words from a local columnist, but no fact-checking

In the area’s second local paper, The Johnstown Tribune-Democrat, columnist Ralph Couey offers a very nice tribute to the heroes of Flight 93 in which he mentions Mr. Burnett’s opposition to the planned memorial. Unfortunately, Mr. Couey goes on to describes Mr. Burnett’s opposition as “hopeless intransigence,” and expresses his optimism that it can be gotten past.

Given that newspapers are supposed to get to the truth, one would hope that those who gain the privilege of this public platform would bother to check the facts. If Mr. Burnett is correct in his warnings about Islamic symbolism, then finding a way to get past these objections is like finding a way to sneak a hijacker past gate security. It is a bad thing, not a good thing.

The petition that Mr. Burnett sponsored along with our blogburst group lists four damning facts about the approved design that can all be verified in a matter of minutes. Can Mr. Couey check just one: that a person standing between the tips of the giant crescent and facing into the center of the crescent will be facing within 2° of Mecca?


The Muslim prayer direction in this animation (qibla) is from the Mecca-direction calculator at Islam.com. (If you have trouble getting their calculator to work–your Java has to be configured correctly–there is another Mecca direction calculator at QiblaLocator.com.)

This Mecca-orientation makes the giant crescent a mihrab, the Mecca-direction indicator around which every mosque is built. Does Mr. Couey really want to see the world’s largest mosque planted on the Flight 93 crash site? It is fine to speak highly of the heroes of Flight 93, but it would be a lot more meaningful if he would honor the Burnett’s urgent appeal for fact-checking by stepping over to a globe and checking this one simple factual claim.

Mr. Couey is not the only one who wants the crescent controversy to go away without caring to know the truth. Sorry, but that is insufficient. Planting a giant Mecca-oriented crescent on the crash-site will dishonor the heroes of Flight 93, and it fails to follow their example. They didn’t just have good intentions. They got the job done, and we have to get the job done too. We can’t be asleep at the wheel while an al Qaeda sympathizing architect hijacks our memorial.

What? Is it just too outlandish to think that the enemy might try to hijack one of our memorials? The same way that it is just too outlandish to think that the enemy might dare to hijack our commercial airliners? Do these people even know what they are memorializing?

But they CAN wake up. All they have to do is actually check the facts. Then they will know. So please Mr. Couey, take the time to check a few facts, then write a second column, reporting your findings. Somebody out there in Somerset needs to start telling the truth. It might as well be you.

To join our blogbursts, just send your blog’s url.

1389 Blog – Antijihadist Tech &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp A Defending Crusader &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp A Fine Line Between Stupid and Clever &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp A Liberal’s Worst Nightmare &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp ACT Golden Gate &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Al Salibiyyah &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp All American Blogger &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Almost Midnight in the West &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp American Commentaries &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp And Rightly So &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Anne Arundel Maryland Politics &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Alamo City Pundit &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp ARRA News Service &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Atlas Shrugs &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Auntie Coosa Campfire Journal &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Bare Naked Islam &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Battle Dress U &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Because I’m Right &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Best Destiny &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Big Dog’s Weblog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Big Sibling &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Blackboot Jacks &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp blogito, ergo, sum &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Bob McCarty Writes &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Boston Maggie &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Cao2’s Weblog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Cao’s Blog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Chaotic Synaptic Activity &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Chester Street Chicago Ray &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Christmas Ghost &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Classic Liberal &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Clay Ritter &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Clay’s Rants and Musings &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Cocked and Loaded &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Colonel Robert Neville Always Dresses for Dinner &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Common Sense Junction &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Concrete Bob &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Covertress &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Creeping Sharia &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp DC Protest Warrior &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Democrat = Socialist &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Dr. Bulldog and Ronin &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Error Theory &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp EW1’s Intercept Log &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Faultline USA &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Flanders Fields &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Flopping Aces &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Founding Fathers of the Vast Right Wing &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Four Pointer &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Francase Place &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Freedom’s Enemies &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Freedom Warrior &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Fried Green Onions &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp From My Position On the Way! &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Ft. Hard Knox &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Freedom Ain’t Free &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Garbanzo Toons &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp General Rachel’s weblog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp GM’s Corner &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Green Country Values &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Gunservatively &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Haid Dasalami &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Hard to Swallow &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Holger Awakens &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Hollywood Conservative &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Hoosier Army Mom &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp iOwnThewWorld.com &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Ironic Surrealism v3.0 &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Ivy League Conservatives &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Jack Lewis &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Jihad Press &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Jim-Rose – the Libertarian Popinjay &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Judge Right &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Just Barking Mad &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp kae’s bloodnut blog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Kender’s Musings &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Lemur King’s Folly &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp LGF 2.0: Little Green Blogmocracy Maggie’s Notebook &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp MELAMPUS’S MENAGERIE!!!! &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Miss Beth’s Victory Dance &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Monkey in the Middle &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Muslims Against Sharia &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp My Own Thoughts &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Neoconstant &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Nice Deb &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp No Apology &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp No Compromises When It Comes To Being Right! &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Noli insipientium iniurias pati Not A Sheep &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Redesigned Flight 93 memorial

still an Islamo-fascist shrine &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Ogre’s Politics and Views &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Old Soldier &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Papa Mike’s blog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Part-Time Pundit &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Political Islam &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Principally Political &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Protest The Church &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Protest The Left &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Publius’ Forum &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Race, Politics, and Religion in the USA &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Rayra.net &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Republican Attack Machine &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Right on the Right &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Right Truth &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Ron’s Musings &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Rosemary’s Thoughts &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Sarah Palin in Español &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Seattle Express &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Sharia Finance Watch &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Sheepdog Barking &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Shot in the Dark &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Sad Old Goth &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Smooth Stone &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Space 4 Commerce by Brian Dunbar &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Stix Blog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Stop the ACLU &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Teen Pundit &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp the Avid Editor &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Conservative Guy &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Gadfly &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Great Lie of Islam &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Grid &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Hinge of Fate &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Liberalguy &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Loyal Eagles &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Midnight Sun &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Mountain &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Paradigm Shift &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Political Octagon &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Renaissance Biologist &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Sanity Sentinel &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Sisyphus Files &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Strata-Sphere &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Truth of Islam &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The View From the Turret &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp The Wide Awakes &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Talk Wisdom &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Thunder Run &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Tizona’s Weblog &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Tough Girl 101 &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Traction Control &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp United Conservatives &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp War of 2 Worlds &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp We Have Some Planes &nbsp&nbsp&nbsp Yes, but can I dance to it?

Copyright Publius Forum 2001